Just Another Spent Milker

Any reasonable person can plainly see that this animal is severely malnourished and in terrible distress.  As a matter of fact, the women who called Pasado’s over a week ago to report this case of animal neglect described her as “walking dead”.  The caller was able to see the extent of the cow’s condition even while traveling over 50 miles per hour in her car on a busy road.  When I arrived on the scene minutes later with hay for the cow and a camera for documenting evidence, I quickly confirmed the caller’s disturbing report. 

My first thought was that if the starving animal standing before me were a dog or a cat instead of a cow the escalation process would be very different.  If she were a companion animal I could have a reasonable chance of seeing the owner who allowed this to happen penalized for their action/inaction. But I know that I’m dealing with the same authorities who had jurisdiction over the last cattle cruelty case to which Pasado’s called. No action has been taken on this case by Snohomish County Animal Control despite overwhelming evidence of severe neglect by the owner of those animals. To date the case has not been referred to the Prosecutor's Office and therefore no charges can be filed against the offender.

Given this situation, I knew my first priority was to find the owner and negotiate a deal.  This cow needed vet care immediately.  Her back hoof was so swollen, inflamed and infected she could not put any pressure on it whatsoever.  Her bones were protruding, she was covered in sores and bald patches and she had severe diarrhea. What kind of human could allow this to happen?  She was initially frightened of me but soon sensed that I was there to help her and eventually allowed me to get close enough to give her some hay and take some pictures.  After knocking on doors and asking around, I located the owner’s home but was not able to talk to him until early the next morning after bringing the cow more food. 

I offered to buy her outright, I offered to have a vet come to the pasture where she was located and treat her or to humanely euthanize her if she could not be treated, all expenses paid.  She had given him 7 or 8 of her calves over the years so he could sell them. She had produced the milk meant for her babies for him to sell and make a buck.  Year after year.  Now, will he allow us to do this for her?   

Nothing would convince him.  Finally I told him that allowing an animal, any animal, to suffer this way was against the law and that I would have to report him to Snohomish County Animal Control.  He calmly stated that he would see me in court and told me to get off his property.  I can only assume that he knew what I feared, that the chances of any farmer being penalized for animal cruelty, no matter what they do or what they allow to happen to the animals under their care, is little to none.

And I was not disappointed.  I called Snohomish County Animal Control, made my report, and I waited for a response my call.  Days passed and no response came.  However, I did not give up.  I continued to fight for her, raising the stakes with the owner, going back to feed her when I could find her, continuing to call Snohomish County Animal Control begging them to do something for her. Only when I contacted the Director of Licensing, the department head that manages Animal Control, did I actually get to talk to someone directly.  I sent the Director, Vicki Lubrin, the pictures of the dying animal, I recounted the week’s events and how we tried to buy the cow before we were forced to make a report.  Still no action. 

Finally, late this week Vicki Lubrin informed me that according to Animal Control the poor creature had been “euthanized” by the farmer.  I hope it’s true, I hope she is out of her misery. They did not offer any additional details. 

However, this matter does not end with her life.  If Animal Control did have a hand in convincing the farmer to do the right thing and release the cow from her suffering, that is a positive outcome.  But their job is to build a case and enforce the law. Pasado's feels that there is a strong case for animal cruelty charges against this farmer and we'll continue to press for exactly that.

And here is why.  This particular farmer stated over and over, “What is the big deal, she’s just one cow? Just another spent milker.” This is true. But last month it was over 20 animals at another farm less than 10 miles away.  How many animals will it be next time?  How long do these creatures have to suffer?  How many must die?  All of these animals were in plain view, easily seen from busy roads. What about all of those who are out of sight, behind walls and in buildings? Someone must fight for them.  They feel pain as any companion animal would. 
We need your help.

Help us build our case for justice for this animal and the others that perished by starvation just a few miles away.  The public does care.  They would not continue to call Pasado's, who they know will provide assistance, if they didn't care.  Snohomish County authorities should care too!  But they routinely dismiss these types of cases as a part of doing business for farmers, and this must stop. 

Send your comments to Vicki Lubrin and Janice Ellis, the Snohomish County Prosecuting Attorney. You can use the following talking points:

  • Animal cruelty should never be tolerated, no matter what species is being victimized
  • As an animal lover I'm concerned about the treatment of animals raised for food.  Humane standards are becoming more and more in demand because so many people around the world feel the very same.
  • Agencies that have the authority to intervene in cruelty and neglect cases and enforce the laws should do so.
  • Animal Control should refer these cases to the Prosecutor's Office as soon as possible.

Submit you comments here

You can also contact the media and tell them that you read about these stories on Pasado's Safe Haven website and encourage them to cover these stories in their newscasts and newspapers.  With enough public scrutiny we may be able see some action and get some justice! Use the talking point below in your own words:

  • I read about yet another farm animal cruelty story on Pasado's Safe Haven website.  Please cover these stories so the public knows that animals who are raised for food and suffer as a result of neglect are falling through the cracks. Their owners should be penalized as any other offender would be.

 

TELEVISION STATIONS

KOMOTV

KINGTV

KIROTV

 

Newspapers

The Seattle Times

The Seattle P-I

The Herald 

 


Copyright © 2009 Pasado's Safe Haven             Pasado's Safe Haven is a 501(c)( 3) non-profit organization.

Charity Navigator, America's premier evaluator of charities, has awarded Pasado's Safe Haven its highest rating, receiving
a 4-Star Rating - for five consecutive years!